Soufisme.org
EN

Can one be a Sufi without being a Muslim?

This is the question most often asked by Westerners interested in Sufism. The honest answer is not a bare ‘yes’ or ‘no’, because two distinct things hide under the phrase ‘being a Sufi’: tasting Sufism, and walking a Sufi path.

What is open to everyone

One can be deeply touched by Sufism without being a Muslim: by Rumi’s poetry, the music of the qawwalis, the reading of the masters, the frequenting of open circles. The Qadiriya Boutchichiya path, for that matter, holds its meditation and dhikr sessions with no religious prerequisite whatsoever: one can come, listen, meditate, ask questions, and never return. Nobody is chased up afterwards; nobody is pressed to convert.

Sufi wisdom itself is universal in its object: the human heart, its veils, its healing. The writings of the masters speak to any conscience that asks itself the question of its own truth.

What walking a path asks

To walk an initiatic path is another matter: it is to enter the tradition from which the path proceeds, that is, Islam. Every Sufi master was or is a Muslim, their disciples are, and the sources of the teaching are the Qur’an and the sunna. The difference between Sufism and Islam being a difference of degree rather than of religion, one cannot follow the third degree (ihsan) while declaring oneself quit of the first two.

Concretely, this means that the disciple who takes the pact (’ahd) receives invocations and engages gradually in the practices of Islam: the prayer, the prescriptions. The path does not demand this ex abrupto: the site’s texts insist on gradualness (‘God wills ease for you; He does not will hardship for you’, Qur’an II, 185), and Westerners who join the path learn the practices at their own rhythm.

And what about Sufism ‘without religion’?

Contemporary offerings sell a Sufism relieved of Islam: poetry, whirling dervishes, music, ‘energy’. That is a legitimate choice of cultural consumption, but it must be called by its name: it is no longer tasawwuf. The tradition itself is clear: a path severed from its revealed source bears only the name of Sufism. The argument is developed in full in our page on Sufism and Islam.

Further reading