Understanding Sufism: definition, relationship to Islam and received ideas
Contents
‘What is Sufism?’ is the most typed query on the site, and one of the most asked of the editorial team. The short answer: Sufism is the inner dimension of Islam, the search for God by the heart. Here are the nuances that frequent questions call for.
What is Sufism?
Sufism, tasawwuf in Arabic, is the inner and spiritual dimension of Islam: the search for proximity to God not through the mere observance of rites, but through invocation (dhikr), meditation, the education of the heart and the company of masters.
The hadith of Jibril, related by al-Bukhari and Muslim, gives its most cited definition. The angel asks the Prophet: ‘What is ihsan?’ He answers: ‘To worship God as if you saw Him, for if you do not see Him, He sees you.’ This ‘excellence’ (ihsan) is the heart of tasawwuf: the consciousness of divine presence in the act itself.
The word itself comes from suf, wool: the first Sufis wore a rough woollen robe, a sign of detachment. The tradition has kept this meaning: Sufism is the stripping away of the ego, not the accumulation of knowledge.
What is the difference between Sufism and Islam?
Sufism is not a religion apart nor a separate branch: it is Islam lived from within. The shari’a, religious law, is the body; tasawwuf is the heart. The two do not oppose each other, they complete each other.
One can be Muslim without being a Sufi: many Muslims pray, fast and perform the rites without committing to a spiritual path. Conversely, the Sufi tradition holds that a Sufism cut off from the Qur’an and the sunna is no longer a tariqa but a spirituality borrowing its vocabulary. The page Sufism and Islam: what is the difference? details this articulation.
Is Sufism a sect?
No, in the sense the word is usually meant. Sufism has neither a separate doctrine nor an organisation that would distinguish it from Islam: it was born in Islam, it lives there, it refers to it. The brotherhoods (turuq) are spiritual filiations, chains of transmission from master to disciple, comparable to the orders in Christianity: they structure practice, they do not create a religion.
What distinguishes a tariqa from a sect is precisely that it does not cut itself off from the tradition: it refers to the Qur’an, the sunna and the recognised masters. The page Can you be a Sufi without being Muslim? specifies what is open and what belongs to commitment.
Is Sufism a mysticism, an esotericism?
It is a mysticism in the strong sense: a direct search for God, spiritual experience, not an abstract doctrine. Ibn ’Arabi, Rumi, al-Junayd, the masters of the path: all describe a journey of the heart towards divine presence.
It is not esoteric in the sense of knowledge reserved to a few initiates: its practices (dhikr, meditation, teaching) are open, and its transmission takes place in clarity. What is ‘inner’ is the work on oneself, not secrecy about things. The page FAQ: Sufism in the West answers other questions of this kind.
What are the most widespread received ideas?
- ‘Sufism is a sect’: no, see above; it is a dimension of Islam.
- ‘It is a Western fashion’: Sufism has a thousand years of history, from Basra to Cairo, from Damascus to Fez; the West is only rediscovering it.
- ‘It is New Age’: Sufism has its sources in the Qur’an and the sunna, its named masters, its chain of transmission; it is not a syncretic spirituality.
- ‘You have to be Arab or Muslim to understand it’: no; the Qadiriya Boutchichiya path welcomes Westerners of all cultures, and the practice (dhikr, meditation) is transmitted beyond language.
For more detailed questions, the hub Questions and answers about Sufism and the page FAQ: Sufism in the West gather the editorial team’s answers. And if the question bringing you here is practical (coming to a session, committing, finding a guide), the page Taking part in Sufism: practical questions answers in the order they arise.
Frequently asked questions
What is Sufism?
Sufism (tasawwuf) is the inner and spiritual dimension of Islam: the search for proximity to God through invocation, meditation and the education of the heart. The hadith of Jibril defines ihsan, its heart, as 'worshipping God as if you saw Him'.
What is the difference between Sufism and Islam?
Sufism is not a religion apart: it is the inner dimension of Islam. The shari'a (the law) is the body, tasawwuf is the heart. One can be Muslim without being a Sufi, but the tradition holds that Sufism without Islam is no longer a path.
Is Sufism a sect?
No. Sufism is not a sect: it has neither a separate doctrine nor an organisation that would distinguish it from Islam. The brotherhoods (turuq) are spiritual filiations inside Islam, like the orders in Christianity.
Is Sufism a mysticism or an esotericism?
Sufism is a mysticism in the strong sense: a direct search for God, not an abstract doctrine. It is not esoteric in the sense of knowledge reserved to a few: its practices (dhikr, meditation, teaching) are open, and its transmission takes place in clarity, not in secrecy.




